What to do about a review you think is fake
Reporting a review is not the same as objecting to it. What the grounds actually are, what evidence helps, and why the review stays visible while it is looked at.
There is a hard distinction at the centre of this, and almost every frustrating moderation experience comes from one side of it being mistaken for the other.
"This review is not from a real customer" is a report. There is a process for it, evidence that moves it, and a decision at the end.
"This review is unfair" is not a report. It is a disagreement, and the reply box is the tool for it.
Both are legitimate feelings. Only one of them is a moderation matter.
What counts as grounds
A review can be removed on published grounds, and only on published grounds. They are:
- It is not about a genuine experience
- There is an undisclosed connection between the reviewer and the business
- It was incentivised and the incentive was not disclosed
- It contains personal information
- It is harassment or a threat
- It is illegal or harmful content
- It is not about this business
What is deliberately not on that list, and will not become grounds however the request is phrased:
- The review is negative
- The business objects to it
- The business has threatened legal action over it
- The business pays for a subscription, at any level
- The facts are disputed and both accounts are plausible
That last one is the one people find hardest. Where a customer remembers one thing and a business remembers another, and neither story is impossible, the review stays and both versions sit on the page. Picking a winner on a balance of two plausible accounts would mean deciding, as a matter of policy, whose memory is worth more.
Before you report: is it actually fake?
Genuine reviews from a bad day look a lot like fakes to the person being reviewed. How to spot a fake review goes through the real signals, but the quick version is that the tells are structural rather than emotional. Vagueness about anything checkable. Details that do not match how you operate. A cluster arriving together. A reviewer with no history and no other reviews anywhere.
A furious review full of specifics — dates, names, what was said — is usually furious and real.
What to submit
This is where reports succeed or fail. A report that says "this never happened" gives a moderator nothing to work with. A report that shows it gives them a decision.
If you are a business, you can dispute a review and submit evidence privately — it is not published, and it is not shown to the reviewer:
- Order or booking records for the period, showing no matching transaction
- Correspondence with the customer that contradicts the account
- Delivery or job records, timestamps, signed sheets
- Evidence of a connection — that the reviewer is a competitor, an ex-employee, or related to one
- Evidence of an undisclosed incentive
- Evidence of extortion: a message demanding a refund or discount in exchange for taking a review down, or threatening one if not
That last category is worth flagging specifically. Using a review, or the threat of a review, to extract money is against the guidelines, and we keep the evidence.
If you are a reader rather than the business, you can report a review too, and the same grounds apply.
What happens next
Automated checks already ran. When a review is submitted, it goes through checks for personal information, threats, promotional content, duplication and authenticity. Most reviews publish immediately; the ones that trip a check do not.
A person decides. A flagged review goes to a moderator, who decides against the published grounds, records a rationale, and cites the clause relied on. Not a model, not a score, not an automatic removal on a report count.
The review stays visible while this happens. It carries an "Under review" label, but it is not hidden. This surprises businesses and it is deliberate: hiding a review the moment anyone complains would make complaining the mechanism, and the volume of complaints would then decide what the public sees.
There is an appeal. If a review is removed and the reviewer appeals, a second and more senior moderator looks at it. Decisions overturned on appeal are counted and published in the quarterly transparency reports — including how often we were wrong.
If the answer is no
Sometimes it will be, and the review stays up.
At that point the reply is the remaining move, and it is a better one than most businesses expect. A calm, specific, non-defensive reply is read by every prospective customer who arrives afterwards, which is a far larger audience than the one person it is addressed to. How to respond to a negative review covers how to write one that helps rather than compounds.
Further reading
- The moderation policy — the grounds and the process in full
- How we handle fraud — the detection side
- Appeals — how a decision gets challenged
- What changed in UK law on fake reviews — why posting or commissioning them is now a different kind of risk
- Why was my review removed — the same process seen from the reviewer's side