Can a business sue you for leaving a bad review?
A legal threat over a review is far more common than a claim that actually goes anywhere. Here is what the law in England and Wales requires a business to prove, and what a platform can and cannot do about the threat.
It happens often enough to be worth writing down. Someone leaves an honest, unflattering review, and a few days later an email arrives using the word "defamatory" and asking for the review to be taken down by Friday.
The letter is designed to be frightening. It is usually much weaker than it sounds.
This is general information about how the law works, not legal advice. If you are facing an actual claim rather than a threatening email, talk to a solicitor.
What a business would have to prove
Defamation in England and Wales runs on the Defamation Act 2013, and the Act was written specifically to stop weak claims being used to silence people. Three parts of it matter here.
Serious harm. Section 1 says a statement is not defamatory at all unless it has caused, or is likely to cause, serious harm to the claimant's reputation. For a business trading for profit, that means serious financial loss — demonstrated, not asserted. One poor review among a page of reviews is a hard place to start that argument.
Truth. Section 2. If what you wrote is substantially true, that is a complete defence. You do not have to have been fair, or kind, or proportionate.
Honest opinion. Section 3, and this is the one most reviews live under. Three conditions: the statement has to be opinion rather than fact, it has to indicate the basis of that opinion, and an honest person could have held it on the facts available at the time. The defence only fails if the business can show you did not actually hold the opinion you expressed.
Read that again, because it is the practical lesson for anyone writing a review: indicates the basis of that opinion. "They are cowboys" is a bare assertion. "They quoted £400, charged £700 and would not explain the difference, so in my view they are not straight with customers" shows its working. The second is far better protected than the first, and it is also a far more useful review.
There is also a one-year limit from publication for bringing a claim.
What the platform does with the threat
Nothing, as far as the review is concerned.
A legal threat from a business is not a ground for removal. Neither is the business objecting, nor the business's subscription level, nor a factual dispute where both accounts are plausible. Those exclusions are written into the moderation policy precisely so that the loudest party does not win by being loudest.
What a business can do is dispute the review and submit private evidence — order records, correspondence, proof the reviewer was never a customer. A moderator weighs that against the published grounds, records a rationale and cites the clause relied on. If the decision goes against the reviewer and they appeal, a second, more senior moderator looks at it. Decisions that get overturned are counted in the published statistics.
A review under dispute is not hidden while that happens. It stays on the page, labelled "Under review", because quietly hiding a review the moment somebody complains is itself a way of deciding the outcome.
Where platforms sit legally
There is a separate defence in section 5 of the Act for website operators hosting content they did not write. It works through a notice procedure set out in the Defamation (Operators of Websites) Regulations 2013, and an operator loses access to it if it ignores a properly made complaint.
The government's own 2019 review of the Act noted that section 5 has barely been used, because operators generally find it easier to take the material down than to work through the procedure. That is the incentive the whole system creates, and it is worth knowing about: a platform that removes a review on the first solicitor's letter is not necessarily acting on the merits. It is taking the cheap option.
What to do if you get one of these letters
Do not panic-delete. You are allowed to stand behind something true.
Re-read what you actually wrote. Is every factual claim in it accurate? Is every judgement clearly a judgement, with its basis visible? If a date or a figure is wrong, correcting it is sensible and not an admission of anything.
Do not reply in anger. Anything you write becomes part of the record.
Keep your evidence. Invoices, messages, photographs, the quote. Honest opinion and truth both depend on what you can show about the facts available to you at the time.
Report the threat. Using a legal threat to force the removal of an honest review is worth us knowing about, and we keep that evidence.
Get advice if it escalates. A letter before action is a different thing from an angry email.
And the thing businesses should hear
The reply box works better than the solicitor. A measured, factual response sits under the review forever and is read by every potential customer who comes afterwards. A removal request, even a successful one, reaches nobody.
If you believe a review is not from a real customer at all, that is a genuinely different situation with a genuine route — what to do about a review you think is fake covers it, and why was my review removed covers the grounds from the other direction.