How to write a review that actually helps someone
Most reviews are a verdict with no evidence. The ones people actually use are specific, dated, and clear about which bits are facts and which are opinions.
"Brilliant service, highly recommended."
"Absolute joke, avoid."
Both of those are real sentiments and neither is any use. The reader cannot tell what happened, when, or whether any of it would apply to them. Five stars with no story is almost as unhelpful as one star with no story.
The good news is that a genuinely useful review takes about ninety seconds longer to write.
Say what you actually bought
Start with the thing itself. A bathroom refit is not a dripping tap. A next-day delivery is not a bespoke order with a six-week lead time. Readers are trying to work out whether your experience predicts theirs, and they cannot do that without knowing what your experience was of.
Say when
Businesses change — new owner, new staff, a better or worse year. An undated review of something that happened in 2021 reads as current and quietly misleads people.
Older experiences are genuinely welcome. Just date them. "This was in spring 2024, before they moved premises" turns a stale review into a useful one.
Separate the facts from the verdict
This is the single biggest improvement available to most reviews, and it does two things at once: it makes the review more useful, and it puts you on much firmer ground if the business takes exception to it.
Weak: "They're a rip-off."
Strong: "The quote was £400. The invoice was £700. When I asked what the extra was for, I was told 'materials' and nothing more. In my view that's not a straight way to do business."
The second version is the same opinion. The difference is that the reader can see what it is built on, decide for themselves, and recognise which part is fact and which is judgement. Can a business sue you for a bad review explains why this structure matters legally as well as editorially.
Include what went right
A review that is entirely negative is less believable than one that is mostly negative. "The fitting was first-rate, the communication was dreadful" is the kind of sentence readers trust, because it sounds like a person rather than a grievance.
The same works in reverse. A five-star review that mentions one small thing that was not perfect reads as honest. One that reads like a press release does not.
What to leave out
Some of this is policy and some is just sense.
- Nobody's personal details — no full names, addresses, phone numbers, order numbers or payment details. Including your own. Reviews are public and permanent.
- Staff names beyond a first name. You can credit the person who helped you by first name. Anything more identifying gets removed.
- Reviews of your own employer, your own business, or a competitor. All three are out.
- Threats and ultimatums. Using a review, or the threat of one, to get a refund or a discount is extortion, and it is treated as such.
Say so if you got something
If you received anything at all in exchange for the review — a discount, a gift, a free upgrade, an entry into a draw — say so in the review itself.
This is worth understanding properly, because people assume disclosure means the review is thrown away. It does not. A disclosed incentive is allowed, and the review stands. It is the hidden incentive that gets a review removed. One line — "I got 10% off for leaving this" — is all it takes, and it makes the review more credible rather than less.
Businesses have the matching obligation: invite every eligible customer rather than a selected group, and never make anything conditional on the rating.
Length
Three or four sentences that say something beat three paragraphs that say the same thing at volume. Write it, then cut the part that is just feeling, and keep the part a stranger could act on.
If you had a bad experience
Write it. Honestly, specifically, and after the adrenaline has gone — an hour later usually produces a better review than the moment it happened, and a better review is a more damaging one in the only way that counts.
And write it knowing a few things: a review will not be removed for being negative, or because the business objects, or because they threaten to sue. The moderation policy says so and the grounds are published. If a review of yours does get removed, why was my review removed explains the reasons and the appeal.
Further reading
- The review guidelines — the rules in full
- How to read a star rating — the other side of the skill
- Verified and unverified reviews — what the badge on a review actually means